Skip to content

How can we help?

Two ways to get your marketing moving. Same vetted experts behind both.

Not sure where to start? Book a Marketing Audit and get a costed 12-month roadmap.

19 Nov 2026

How to Hire a Marketing Manager When You’re Not a Marketer

Not a marketer but need to hire one? Learn how to define the role, read a marketing CV, test candidates at interview and avoid the most costly hiring mistakes.

Blog
pexels-edmond-dantes-4344878

Hiring your first marketing manager usually means marketing has reached a point where it can no longer be managed between sales calls, customer conversations, and the daily demands of running the company. The business needs someone who can bring order to it and turn it into a more reliable source of growth.

The challenge is that many business owners are not marketers themselves. They understand their customers, their industry and their product better than anyone, but they may not know how to judge whether a marketing candidate has genuine strategic ability or simply knows how to present themselves well.

Hiring a marketing manager does not require you to become a marketing expert. It requires knowing how to define the role, understand what good candidates look like, and ask questions that reveal how someone thinks.

Start With Understanding What You Actually Need

The most common mistake businesses make when hiring a marketing manager is starting with the job title rather than the business problem.

“Marketing manager” can mean very different things depending on the organisation.

Marketing consultant walking a client through a pricing proposal

In one company, the role may involve managing social media, coordinating content, and supporting campaigns. In another, the person may be expected to create the entire marketing strategy, manage budgets, lead suppliers, and generate measurable revenue growth.

Before advertising the position, business owners should first understand what they need marketing to achieve.

It is also tempting to look for someone who can “do everything”. Marketing covers many different disciplines, including strategy, paid advertising, SEO, content, analytics, brand positioning and customer research. Very few people are strong across all of them, so decide which ones matter most and hire for those.

Understand the Difference Between a Marketing Manager and a Marketing Leader

A marketing manager is often responsible for execution. They may coordinate campaigns, manage suppliers, create reports, and oversee day-to-day marketing activity.

A marketing leader focuses on direction. They determine who the business should target, which channels deserve investment, what message the company should communicate, how marketing performance should be measured, and what resources are needed for growth.

A company that needs someone to manage existing activity may not need senior leadership. However, a business expecting a marketing manager to create strategy, build systems, manage a team, and deliver growth without support may be creating an unrealistic role.

This is why many growing businesses explore fractional marketing leadership before committing to a senior full-time hire. If you are weighing up that option, Cemoh’s free fractional CMO guide is a useful place to start.

How to Read a Marketing CV When You Are Not a Marketer

Business owner reviewing a marketing candidate's CV at her des

Reviewing marketing CVs can be difficult because many candidates describe activities rather than outcomes. “Managed social media channels” tells you what someone was responsible for. “Grew enquiries from LinkedIn over six months” tells you what changed because they were there.

Good marketers understand that marketing is not simply about producing activity. It is about creating business value.

When reviewing a candidate’s experience, focus less on the number of tools they have used and more on whether they understand customers, strategy, measurement, and commercial outcomes.

How to Test Marketing Capability During Interviews

Many business owners avoid testing marketing candidates because they feel they do not know enough about marketing themselves. However, you do not need to test every technical skill. Instead, focus on how candidates approach problems.

A strong marketer will ask questions before offering answers. They will want to understand your customers, competitors, sales process, existing performance and business objectives.

A weaker marketer may suggest running ads, posting more content, or redesigning a website before understanding the underlying problem.

Look for Someone Who Connects Marketing With Business Growth

The biggest difference between average marketers and exceptional marketers is their ability to connect activity with outcomes.

Marketing manager explaining campaign results on a laptop dashboard to colleagues

Ask candidates how they measured success in previous roles. Strong answers link marketing activity to numbers the business cares about, such as enquiries, conversion rates, sales pipeline or customer retention. Weaker answers stop at impressions, clicks or follower counts.

The First 90 Days Reveal a Lot About a Marketer

A strong marketing manager should not walk into a business promising instant transformation.

The first 90 days should usually involve reviewing existing activity, understanding customers, analysing performance data, identifying quick wins, and creating a clear roadmap.

A marketer who spends time learning before making major changes is often demonstrating stronger strategic thinking.

They understand that effective marketing decisions come from evidence, not assumptions.

The Mistake Cemoh Sees Most Often: Hiring the Wrong Level of Capability

A common challenge Cemoh sees is businesses hiring marketers before understanding the capability they actually need.

One company may hire a junior marketer expecting them to create strategy and lead growth. Another may hire an expensive senior marketer when they actually need specialist execution support.

In both cases, the problem is not necessarily the person hired. The problem is the mismatch between the business requirement and the role.

Cemoh helps Australian businesses access experienced marketing professionals who can provide strategic guidance, specialist expertise, and support while companies build their internal capability.

Businesses looking for experienced marketing talent can explore options to hire marketers through Cemoh.

Should You Hire a Marketing Manager or Get Strategic Support First?

A consultant or fractional marketing leader can help identify what the business actually needs, which skills are missing, and what type of person should be hired next.

This helps you avoid hiring someone before you understand the problem they need to solve.

The right order is often:

  • Understand the business objective.
  • Define the marketing strategy.
  • Identify capability gaps.
  • Then hire for the skills required.

Final Thoughts: Hire for Thinking, Not Just Tasks

You do not need to know how to run a campaign to hire someone who can. Be clear about the outcomes you need, look for evidence of results on the CV, and use the interview to see how candidates think through a problem.

The best marketing managers understand customers, think strategically, communicate clearly, and connect marketing activity with business outcomes.

For businesses building their marketing function, Cemoh connects organisations with experienced marketing professionals who can provide the right expertise at different stages of growth.

View all
Blogs

Related posts

Here are some suggested articles that are closely related to this post

What Your Marketing Team Should Look Like by Business Size

What Your Marketing Team Should Look Like by Business Size

Building an effective marketing team is crucial for business success, but what is the correct structure of that team based on the size of a business? From micro businesses with just a couple of employees to enterprises with hundreds and thousands,..

What Is Digital Marketing Consulting?

What Is Digital Marketing Consulting?

What is digital marketing consulting and how does it work? We explain what a consultant does, why you need one, and how to hire the right partner in Australia.